Cantiello's logic? The "Idol" obsessive explained that Brown and Garcia have massive hometown fanbases — Brown's apparently made up of Texas churchgoers and Garcia's of his thousands of YouTube fans — and good-girl high schooler Stevens has the "grandma vote" locked up. "So, that leaves Casey, who was especially forgettable, having gone third in the show's two-hour lineup. That's a pretty brutal spot to be in."